4 Dumb Things People Do During Interviews

4 Dumb Things People Do During Interviews

by Kerry Scott on 22 June 2009

2616233530_d6f9c41a3fPhoto by Christina Snyder

You know what a STAR question is, right?

It’s those interview questions where you’re supposed to give a:

S/T — Situation/Task

A —  Action You Took

R — Result You Achieved

See, it spells out STAR.  That’s so you (and the interviewer) remember what you’re supposed to do.  Yeah, it’s a goofy little acronym.  But this interview technique (or a close variation of it) is used by most big companies, and quite a few small ones as well.  It’s part of behavior-based interviewing, which essentially works on the idea that past behavior is the best predictor of future behavior…so interviewers want to know what you’ve done in the past, to understand whether you might be successful in the future.  You need to know how to work with this type of question.

Some people just can’t work within this framework, and they manage to blow the interview by not being able to get through the questions effectively.  Here are the four most common mistakes I’ve seen candidates make in this type of interview:

  1. Not listening to the question. Interviewing can be nerve-racking.  Everyone gets that.  But if I’m repeatedly asking you to tell me about a time when you had to deal with interpersonal conflict, and you keep telling me about how you studied for the CPA exam, you’re telling me you’re not a good listener.  That’s bad.  Employers choose these questions up front to focus on the skills and traits they think are most important for this job.  You need to give them what they want.  Incidentally, if you can remember what the questions were, you’ll have pretty good insight into what they’re looking for in a candidate.  That will help for subsequent interviews, and help you know what to reinforce when writing your thank-you notes.
  2. Giving hypothetical answers. These types of interview questions always start with “Tell me about a time…” or “Describe a time…” or something like that.  That means they’re looking for a specific example from your past.  Don’t try to cheat, because trust me when I tell you that you will annoy the crap out of them in doing so.  If I say, “Tell me about a time when you had to deal with a personality clash at work,” you should never say, “Oh, I would talk it out with them; I would do this and that and the other thing.”  I don’t want to hear what you would do.  I want to know what you did do.  Everyone is perfect in hypothetical situations; I want to know about your real-life experience.  If you can’t tell me about that, you either don’t have that experience or you’re not really listening.  Now, there are times when you really don’t have the experience they’re asking about.  It’s fine to say, “I’ve never actually done X, but here’s how I think I’d handle that.”  That way, you’re letting them know that you heard and understood the question just fine, but you just don’t have an experience that matches what they’re asking about.  It’s much better to admit you’ve never done something up front than to pretend you’re not really understanding the question.
  3. Giving disorganized answers. The reason somebody invented that STAR acronym is so that interviewers and candidates could organize their answers in a succinct, meaningful way.  Make sure you do that.  Clearly describe the situation (I had a co-worker who was constantly playing her iPod on the stereo in the next cube, and she played ‘Poker Face’ over and over and over again).  Then clearly describe the action you took (I went to her and told her that I sometimes found the music distracting, and I wondered if we could work out a solution that would work for both of us).  Then describe the result (We agreed that since I’m in meetings most mornings, she’d play whatever she wanted then, and that in the afternoon she could only play “Poker Face” five times).  It’s okay to pause and organize your thoughts before you begin to answer the question…anything to avoid a rambling mess.
  4. Giving bad results. Sometimes people are so nervous in interviews that they don’t really think about their answers to questions.  They just start talking.  As a result, some candidates get to the “results” part of these questions, and either find that they have a lousy result (She played “Poker Face” 27 times between noon and 2:30 the next day, so I beat her to death with my stapler) or no result at all (My boss moved me to a new cube farm the next day, so I never saw her again, and as far as I know she is still playing “Poker Face” to an unsuspecting victim).  It seems obvious, but you’d be surprised how few people choose stories with outcomes that actually make them look good.  Again, it’s totally fine to pause and think before you begin answering a question.

Mastering the art of answering these types of questions will put you way ahead of the pack in terms of interviewing.  In fact, thinking of your career experience in terms of situations/actions/results is a good exercise for resume writing and networking too.  The better you are at clearly and concisely describing why you’re fabulous, the more likely you are to convince someone else to hire you.

Facebook Twitter Linkedin Stumbleupon Email

Other posts you might like:


Charles June 22, 2009 at 9:29 am

“Yeah, it’s a goofy little acronym.”

Hey, whatever works. As a trainer, I use them all the time. (control +V for “Velcro”)

Anything that can help one remember stuff is good – no matter how corny or goofy. In fact, I find that the cornier, the easier it is to remember!

HRPufnstuf June 22, 2009 at 4:03 pm

Great advice!

carla June 22, 2009 at 5:58 pm

This is something for me to remember if I ever have to interview for a position in the future. I get way too nervous so I sometimes have a hard time coming up with the “correct” (ie. tell then want they want to hear) answers.

carla’s last blog post..Poll: What are you doing?

abdpbt June 22, 2009 at 6:11 pm

Hey, nice implementation of the LinkWithin widget grasshopper.

abdpbt’s last blog post..18 Tweets Made By Spoiled Kings

Ask a Manager June 22, 2009 at 6:41 pm

Thank you, thank you, thank you! Especially for #2, re: candidates answering with hypotheticals. I had a candidate continually do this last week, and I kept saying, “Actually, can you tell me about a specific situation in your past?” She never really got it.

Ask a Manager’s last blog post..how to get a reputation for credibility

Tim G June 23, 2009 at 10:10 pm

And if you get asked a question about how you handled conflict, don’t reply that you like working with people, and never really have any problems with anyone. Conflict isn’t always about people being difficult with one another, it’s also about bringing diverse opinions into higher-level results. Experience with conflict is generally a good thing, never having conflicts is generally not believable.

Tim G’s last blog post..It’s Good To Investigate

Bob Corlett June 23, 2009 at 11:13 pm

This is refreshingly, astonishingly accurate. Job seekers, this is pure gold. I’ve been in executive search for 20 years, and you can rest assured that I’ll be mentally checked out about 10 minutes into your interview if you violate these principles. Kerry you do job seekers a great service with posts like these.

Bob Corlett’s last blog post..Stop Thinking About the National Economy

Comments on this entry are closed.

{ 2 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: